Column
AI Generated Image
All one has to do is dip into Facebook and observe the ongoing discussion on AI use. Just about everyone is concerned, worried and angry about the boundaries that AI has crossed into the human space and may will more in the future.
While many ordinary citizens on the net worry about losing income and a life without control or controlled by "remote machines", it holds a special space of anxiety for the intellectuals and specifically authors. Are they going to remain relevant and useful with their identity and professional labour intact?
It's a valid question and something which is on almost all creative minds. So many factors are responsible and so many dimensions exist that a simple "this will happen "or "" this won't happen" doesn't work anymore to present a precise picture of an uncertain future. So many factors, elements and players are involved.
Thus if someone asks a question of that genre, I think the most interesting and productive way to find an answer would be to ask an AI what it thinks will be the situation. Which is what I did and the substance of what my Gemini Google AI said was the following. The edited version is below.
What AI says
AI said that recent academic studies and industry surveys show a complex picture: while readers often rate AI-generated stories as engaging or high-quality when they do not know the author is one, a large majority of consumers state that they would not buy or prefer books written entirely by AI.
The Villanova University Study ("Bot or Not")
Published in the journal "Judgement and Decision Making" (August 2026), researchers Sydney Sears and Dr. Deena Skolnick Weisberg from Villanova University tested how participants reacted to short stories written by humans versus ChatGPT. Their findings were as follows:
• Quality Ratings: When readers were not told who wrote the story, AI-generated short stories often received higher scores for quality and engagement than human-written fiction. Large language models are optimised via human feedback to appeal to broad, mainstream preferences. So, it's like a pre-tested literary product which will naturally be more attuned to general public taste.
• The Labelling Bias: When participants were told a story was written by a human-even if it was actually written by AI-they rated it higher. Conversely, knowing a story was written by AI lowered its perceived emotional resonance and predictability.
• Identification Accuracy: In blind tests, participants could only identify whether a story was written by AI or a human 40% to 52% of the time (barely better than a random guess).
Industry and Reader Surveys on Buying Habits
While people may enjoy or get absorbed by an AI story on a blind read, commercial and reader-preference surveys show strong resistance to purchasing AI-authored books:
Thriller Writers (ITW) Survey: Preference and collaboration
A survey on book-buying preferences found that:
• 73.3% of readers would not buy a book written entirely using AI.
• 93.5% of readers would not buy a book written entirely by AI even if it was much cheaper than books written by humans.
• 97.1% believe publishers should be required to explicitly state on the cover if a book has been written using AI. (AI content ends)
So, the preference is clear. Good, bad, indifferent, humans prefer humans. So, it's not about quality of literature but species loyalty which is about genetic anthropology and not literary value. In other words, it's about sustaining the supremacy of humans as producers of value.
If that is understood, we can better understand why human reaction to AI generated literature is so intense. Humans fear extinction. In this case it seems about literature but essentially our evolutionary biologically evolved brains are responding to a threat to the species not to a product.
Collaborative and Conversational AI Storytelling
In contrast to traditional published fiction, informal and interactive AI storytelling has massive real-world engagement:
• Millions of users actively engage in roleplay, branching narratives, and collaborative fiction writing with AI chatbots and companion apps (with estimates suggesting tens of millions of people interact with or shape fiction using AI tools, often without labelling it as formal "writing".
And this is where the issue becomes not about writing but the science of evolution.
What the future may look like
Every high intensity change has faced resistance in history in whichever field they may be. But over time they have evolved and the threat has turned into a collaboration and a new identity emerges. Whether it's the earlier industrial revolution which replaced the hand craftsmen or the computer which made handwriting irrelevant, there has been resistance loud and wide.
But ultimately co-existence and co-operation happens because if anything threatens the human species as a whole, they will make the threat a part of their own survival and turn it into a partner not an enemy.
So, all kinds of combinations are inevitable: Human created. AI created and co-created. Already this is happening and discussions are on about declaring AI co-authorship as legitimate. Already about 30% AI use in academic writings are allowed so it's a matter of degree, not principle anymore.
That's how it has always been. Humans first resist and if the threat is beyond control, they simply adopt. It's probably not going to be any different in this case too.
Evolution always wins.

















Leave a Comment
Recent Posts
Shenzhen was no Yalta: The Lim ...
The meeting between US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladi ...
For the first time, UN’s highe ...
In a landmark judgment, the United Nations’ top court ruled Thur ...
DFC engagement to mobilise private investment, advan ..
France to celebrate French Week in Dhaka; André Malr ..
The Roots of Macron’s Failure
The Silver Lining of a Data-Center Slowdown